The aim of the project ‘råd & VINK’ (‘hints
and advice’ is to produce a web-based
tutorial in information literacy for students
in Norway. The project is a collaboration
between the libraries of Telemark University
College (HiT) and Stord/Haugesund University
College (HSH). The tutorial is expected
to be ready by October 2004 when
it will be made freely available on the web.
The tutorial consists of two main parts. In
the first part the student is led through the
research process: finding a topic, defining
and refining a research question, finding
information, evaluating sources and preparing
to write the assignment. The second
part consists of a tool box of information
literacy skills and links to guides and
resources.
The libraries of HiT and HSH are working
to improve their teaching in library
and information use to students on
campus and to the growing number of
distance learning and part-time students.
A web tutorial and guide is seen
as an aid in this task. At the time of
planning the project, we were not aware
of any Norwegian language tutorials,
and saw, therefore, the need to create a
tutorial ourselves.
The aim of the project is to create an
interactive web-based tutorial in information
literacy for students. It should
be possible to use the tutorial as a part
of the library’s face-to-face teaching,
and also as selfpaced self-instruction.
The tutorial will be module-based and
it will be freely available on the web.
The term ‘information literacy’ can be
interpreted in many ways. It is often
used as a synonym for library skills,
information skills and computer skills.
We have chosen to adopt the description
formulated by the American Library
Association in 1989: “To be information
literate, a person must be able to recognise
when information is needed
and have the ability to locate, evaluate,
and use effectively the needed information.”
This description forms the basis
for information literacy standards in
higher education in USA (ACRL 2000)
and Australia (CAUL 2001).
Teaching methods such as group work,
problem-based learning (PBL) and
project work require that the student is
competent in the acquisition and use
of relevant information. However, libraries
often experience that students
are not sufficiently information literate
even though they have attended library
education and information literacy
courses. A study made as part of the
Godin Project at the University of Roskilde
in Denmark showed that students
soon forgot what they had learned at
the information literacy course (Clas
Poulsen, 2002). This is in accordance
with our own observations.
Why is this so? There seems to be two
main reasons. Firstly, information literacy
teaching or library skills teaching
is not usually an integrated part of the
main course curriculum, but is just an
‘add on’. It can, therefore, be difficult to
motivate the student to see it as an essential
part of studying. Secondly, most
librarians do not have the necessary
teaching skills to motivate the students
to learn new strategies. According to
Sharon Markless, librarians “… spend
time helping users to develop the strategies
that they need to exploit resources
and to use information more effectively.
However, it is not easy for
people to adopt new strategies: such
changes in behaviour cannot simply be
handed over to users.”
After a literature study in educational
theories, androgogy, web learning and
web design, we concluded that we need
to design a web tutorial with the main
emphasis on the research process
rather than on the technicalities of information
searching. It should stimulate
the student to active participation,
problem solving and reflection. We
searched for web tutorials in English
and the Scandinavian languages to see
if an existing tutorial could be translated
into Norwegian and adapted to
our needs.We found only one tutorial
which we considered to be totally process-
orientated, rather than task-orientated
– the Danish tutorial SWIM.
SWIM looks at information literacy
from the student’s point of view.
“SWIM is a social simulator based on
interactive video, where the user has to
reflect on and make decisions on information
searching strategy in different
dilemmas.” (Niels Jørgen Blåbjerg,
2003). In addition to the role play,
there are five modules, which go into
the information search process in more
detail. SWIM presents information literacy
in a very realistic way and is
extremely student-orientated. However,
we found the sequences in the role play
to be rather long at times and the feedback
confusing. The navigation was
also rather rigid in the role play section.
Re-recording and dubbing the Danish
dialogues in Norwegian would be
prohibitively expensive.
SWIM is based on Carol Kuhlthau’s Information
Search Process (ISP) (Kuhlthau
1993).We found this model for information
searching interesting. It places
more emphasis on the early stages
of the research process than many
other models. It has six phases: task
initiation, topic selection and prefocus
formulation, focus formulation, information
collection and search closure.
It also incorporates dimensions such as
thoughts, feelings and mood in addition
to actions and strategies.
Comic strips as a guide
We decided to base our tutorial on
Kuhlthau’s model and to use SWIM as
our inspiration.We saw the need for a
process-orientated tutorial covering the
complete research process from the
time the student receives the assignment
to the completion of the paper.
At the same time, the student should
be able to find specific information on
information literacy skills.
The process-orientated part of the
tutorial will consist of a series of situations
consistent with Kuhlthau’s six
phases. The situations will be presented
in the form of a comic strip showing a
group of students who are doing a project.
After each sequence, the user will
be presented with a choice of actions
and strategies. The user will get immediate
feedback on his/her choice and
will be able to click on links to further
information if required.
This additional information will also
be available in the form of a tool box
which will contain guides in information
searching techniques and strategies,
search guides to specific databases and
catalogues, evaluation techniques, study
techniques and writing techniques.
The tool box will function as a reference
work, where the user can pick and
choose from the tool box according to
his or her needs.
At the time of writing, the manuscript
for the process-orientated part has
been completed and an illustrator and
a web designer are working on the web
presentation. The project co-workers
have started on the content and construction
of the box. Here we are looking
at the many existing web tutorials
in order to find good ways of presenting
the information in regard to content,
pedagogy and information design.
The aim is to test out the tutorial on
student groups in September in order
to make any necessary adjustments
before the final launch in the middle of
October 2004.
List of references
- American Library Association Presidential Committee on Information Literacy (1989)
- Final report. Chicago: ALA.
- Association of College and Research Libraries (ACRL) (2000)
- Information literacy competency standards for higher education. Chicago: ACRL.
http://www.ala.org/Content/NavigationMenu/ACRL/
Standards_and_Guidelines/standards.pdf
- Blåbjerg, Niels Jørgen (2003)
- Information learning strategies (SWIM) In: Knowledge III. Information
literacy, bridging the gap between teaching and learning promoting the
educational role of the librarian, Akureyri, Iceland - September
25-26, 2003.
http://vefir.unak.is/CKIII/default.htm
- Council of Australian University Librarians (CAUL) (2001)
- Information literacy standards. Canberra:Council of Australian University
Librarians.
http://www.caul.edu.au/caul-doc/InfoLitStandards2001.doc
- Kuhlthau, Carol Collier (1993)
- Seeking meaning: a process approach to library
and information services. - Norwood, N.J.: Ablex, 1993.
- Markless, Sharon (2003)
- Information literacy: a learning-focussed approach. In: Creating Knowledge
III. Information literacy, bridging the gap between teaching and learning
promoting the educational role of the librarian, Akureyri, Iceland - September
25-26, 2003.
http://vefir.unak.is/CKIII/default.htm
- Poulsen, Claus (2002)
- Problembaseret undervisning i informasjonssøgning: teori, erfaringer, metode
og undervisningsmateriale. Roskilde: Roskilde Universitetsbibliotek. (Godin
projektet. Slutrapport) (Skriftserie fra Roskilde Universitetsbibliotek nr. 38)
http://www.rub.ruc.dk/rub/omrub/skrserie/slutrapport.pdf